We'll toss out Paltrow.
This competition comes down to the former Friends star in Aniston and the do-good actress, Jolie.
Back in 1999, Aniston's ring, which she debuted during a Sting concert in NYC, was estimated to be worth around $500,000; jewelry expert Michael O'Connor recently quoted Jolie's new bauble to be approximately $250,000.
So what do you think? Who got the prettier/better rock from Brad? And how do you like his design abilities since it's been well reported he took a year to design Jolie's ring?
Here's Jen's former bauble:
And here's Angelina's (I'm using the photo from our Facebook page that also includes a screenshot of comments — clearly it's drawn mixed reviews among INSTORE's audience. Feel free to weigh in and leave a comment of your own below):